I agree with all of this, but Klein misses the most important fact: wages are taxed, employer-provided health coverage is not. That seems like a pretty important distinction to me, since the marginal tax rate for most Americans is 40%. If average health benefits equal $13,500 in extra compensation as Klein says, the typical worker saves 40% of that, or $5,400 a year, by receiving it in the form of health coverage rather than cash.
I don't think that's the way it should be, but that's the way it is. I agree with Klein's calls for transparency, but that points in both directions. By not admitting that fact, Klein has done his readers a disservice.
IPE @ UNC
IPE@UNC is a group blog maintained by faculty and graduate students in the Department of Political Science at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The opinions expressed on these pages are our own, and have nothing to do with UNC.
Tags
Blog Archive
-
►
2012
(51)
-
►
May
(17)
- When Did the Dollar Become the World's Reserve Cur...
- Asymmetry in Global Markets
- Being Relatively Unconcerned About Concerning Thin...
- Brinksmanship and Grexit
- Good Sense and Critical Intelligence
- Defending Social Science Against Those Who Would P...
- Poking Macroeconomists with a Stick
- There Is No Technocracy: China Central Banking Edi...
- Austerity v. Drudgery
- Am I Reading This Wrong?
- There Is No Technocracy: Partisan Bias at the Fed
- Rules vs. Principles in Regulation
- Soapbox
- The Coming Anarchy?
- Redistributive Cooperation, Redux
- Yet Another for the Materialists (?)
- Score Another One for the Materialists
-
►
February
(8)
- There Is No Technocracy, Bank of Japan Edition
- Conflict Scholars Should Learn Political Economy I...
- What Argentina Says About Greece
- Brinksmanship in Political Economy
- Climate Change, Development, and Conflict
- Winning the Future
- The World Is Still Not a Dyad
- Slower Chinese Growth Could Be Good for the Global...
-
►
January
(13)
- Definitely Not Expansionary, Maybe Not Even Auster...
- Global Financial Markets FOTD
- A Debate I'd Like to See
- There Is No Great Stagnation, Only Great Integrati...
- It's A System, Not a Dyad
- SOTU Bingo
- Paradigms in Political Science
- Interests, Ideas, and MIT Economists
- (Terrible, No Good) GOTD
- Why Theories of Regulation Are Inadequate
- Economists Are Not Doctors
- Academic Publishers Are Evil
-
►
May
(17)
-
▼
2009
(521)
-
▼
December
(48)
- J. David Singer, RIP
- China's Choice: How to Adjust
- Fix Up, Look Sharp
- Weekend Links
- New Protests in Iran
- Terrorism and TSA Restrictions on Passengers
- Please: Don't Be Evil
- Santa Claus: International Trade Criminal
- Hearts and Minds
- Economics Smackdown
- When Bad News Is Good News Is Bad News
- CPI - Christmas Price Index
- Lee Sigelman, RIP
- Suggestion Box
- The Year's Best in Global Political Economy
- Hossein Ali Montazeri, RIP
- Copenhagen
- Quote(s) of the Day
- Distilling Great Thinkers
- Midweek Links
- Mother Superior Gets Published
- TARP Makes More Money
- So Lemme Get This Straight
- Relative Prices and the Real Estate Bubble
- Weekend Links
- Hegemonic Instability Theory
- Scary Words
- Links
- Re-examining NAFTA
- What Causes Economic Growth?
- We're Better Than You
- Opa!
- Making Transparency More Transparent
- The Diffusion of Labor Rights
- The Curious Case of the Missing $100bn
- Gaming Chinese Marriages
- The Methodologists' Lament
- First-Year Reading List
- Parsing the Efficient Markets Hypothesis
- Why Does Krugman Have to Keep Doing This?
- Playing Mind Games with the Fed
- Could Greece Default?
- Russian Government Advocates Punching Russian Poli...
- Midweek Links
- Road Tripping: Obama in Afghanistan (or, Why Obama...
- North Korea Redenominates Currency
- Paging Tom Colburn
- True Words
-
▼
December
(48)
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Making Transparency More Transparent
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

0 comments:
Post a Comment