Emmanuel wonders whether the IMF can lend to Greece, because Greece faces a funding problem but not a balance of payments problem. Because the IMF exists to fund governments facing balance of payments problems, Greece doesn't or shouldn't qualify for IMF assistance.
- ► 2013 (95)
- ► 2012 (129)
- ► 2011 (365)
- The Curse of Carabosse?
- Question of the Day
- Revealed Preferences
- Greece, the Euro, and the IMF
- Even More Against Immigration Pharisees
- I'm passing this along without comment, except to ...
- Against the Immigration Pharisees
- Workers of the World, Divide!
- What Do We Know About Terrorism?
- More on the (Lack of an) Anti-Globalization Moveme...
- Will the Last Anti-Globalizationist Turn Off the L...
- Anything Hugo Can Do, Evo Can Do Better
- Happy Birthday, Vladimir Ilyich Lenin
- What Can We Learn from Politicians' Reading Habits...
- Why We Can't, and Shouldn't, Eliminate Bailout Gua...
- Housing Policy and Labor Bargaining Power
- Complexity Is Not Evil
- Hard Problems in Social Science
- How Marx and Engels Got Politics Wrong
- Warning Signs in Europe
- Sunday Morning Talk Shows
- Walk On
- There Are Idiots
- Monetary Policy Is Not Magic
- Research at UNC
- In Favor of Bailout Guarantees
- ▼ April (28)
- ► 2009 (521)
- ► 2008 (134)
- ► 2007 (142)
Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Posted by Thomas Oatley at 10:24 PM . Wednesday, April 28, 2010
Yet, Greece does have a balance of payments problem. Its current account deficit is about 6% of GDP. I can't imagine that it is not experiencing net capital outflows at present. The question is, then, from whom can Greece borrow to cover its twin deficits when markets are reluctant to lend at less than penalty rates?
Greek banks can't borrow from the ECB without limit. If Greece could borrow from the ECB without limit, it wouldn't be facing its current crisis. And the Germans wouldn't be wringing their hands and dragging their feet over the proposed extra-ordinary funding. If Greece could borrow without limit from the ECB, it would sell bonds to the ECB and use the euro to settle its current deficit. This is exactly the contingency that made the Germans reluctant to throw their lot in with the PIGs to begin with and makes them reluctant to support Greece now. The Germans are reluctant because this monetizes Greece's deficit and produces inflation.
The situation in Greece is therefore no different, fundamentally, than the Argentinian crisis or the bigger Latin American crisis of the 1980s. So of course the IMF is mandated to lend to Greece.