Tuesday, June 7, 2011

*The Origins of Political Order*

. Tuesday, June 7, 2011
0 comments

Francis Fukuyama has what looks like a Big, Important book out by that title, but I haven't seen much discussion. He was on Colbert, and Cowen got to it, but little from political scientists. Too soon?

There Is No Great Stagnation, Only Great Redistribution

.
11 comments



Tyler Cowen's The Great Stagnation has gotten a lot of attention for both its form and content. (I.e., there's more than a little irony in the fact that a book alleging that technological progress has markedly slowed was the first notable electronic-only book, although it has since been released in pulp-and-glue as well.) In the video above he presents his main thesis at TEDxEast. For those unaware, the argument runs basically like this: since 1973 or thereabouts, there has been a slowdown in median American income growth, and that trend has increased in the past decade. That slowdown is mostly attributable to a decline in technological innovation. We've reaped the gains of past innovations -- cars, planes, electricity, plumbing -- but haven't made many new ones. We tweak the old innovations to our advantage -- we've made cars safer and added GPS -- but those are marginal improvements, not fundamental advances. The exception is the internet and communications more generally, but while those improve quality of life they do little to improve typical incomes.

Cowen's argument has bothered me on a number of levels. First, I think he understates the real, and monetary, value of the internet and improved communications technology for standards of living. Second, I think he makes a mistake by looking almost entirely at the U.S., and almost entirely at median income. I want to focus on the second of these, placing it in the context of the first.

I'm really late to this party... Cowen's book has been covered by everyone in the blogosphere and almost everyone in the corporate press, so I'm sure someone has written more or less exactly what I'm about to write, but I've haven't seen it in quite this form before. So to see why I think Cowen's thesis is wrong, or at least incomplete, let's start with some global data.



This graph shows global real gdp per capita from 1960-2009 (blue line). I've highlighted 1973's income level -- $1,148 -- to show what the world looked like around the time that Cowen thinks the Great Stagnation started in the US. In the following 35 years, per-person income increased by nearly 800%. If the pre-1973 trend had continued (red line), that number would be more than halved. If growth post-1973 had stagnated, we'd be below the red line. But that didn't happen, as we can see from this series. First, global growth in the 1970s was faster than in the 1960s. And while that trend wasn't consistent through the 1980s and 1990s (dark green line), global GDP growth in the 2000s was the fastest during the period. In fact, by the end of the decade we'd caught back up to where we'd be if the 1970s trend had been consistent, before the financial crisis knocked us back a bit. But the story here is of pretty rapid growth on a global scale that actually accelerated in the most recent decade. No Great Stagnation, on a global level at least.

Cowen agrees that global growth has been strong as other countries adopt the innovations the U.S. has already exploited. This "catch-up" growth may be fine for developing countries, which have a lot of low-hanging fruit, but he wants to focus on those at the edge of the technology frontier, especially the US. So let's look at what's happened to US growth over the same period.



The green line represents approximately where US incomes would be if we had stayed at the pre-1973 rate of growth. Average incomes would be less than half what they are now. If the economy had stagnated, as Cowen claims, average incomes would be below the green line. Instead, the rate of US growth actually increased over that period, at a more rapid pace even than the increase in global growth depicted in the first graph. This doesn't look like stagnation at all, much less a Great Stagnation. So what is Cowen going on about?



Ah, the picture looks a bit different if you compare mean GDP/capita to median GDP/capita. Before 1973 the two tracked each other very closely. Post-1973, mean GDP/capita (the white circles) kept growing at roughly the pre-1973 trend rate, while median GDP/capita (black diamonds) stagnated. But the economy overall did not. Just median incomes. That indicates, to me, that Cowen's preferred causal mechanism -- a stagnation due to slowdown in innovation -- is missing what's actually happened. There's been enough growth, it just hasn't gone to the median earner. The result has been higher inequality.

Why has that happened? Theories abound. Some political scientists have recently made the case that rising inequality is a result of wealthy groups hijacking politics for their own economic benefit. In other words, the distribution of growth is zero-sum, and it's been redistributed towards the wealthy in the form of tax cuts, decline in union membership, erosion of the welfare state, and deregulation. I think there's something to that, but I think it's too focused on developments specific to the US. To get the whole picture, I think we need to situate the US in a global context.

It's difficult to find reliable estimates of global median income in a time series (in fact I couldn't... pointers welcome), but indications are that inequality is increasing within many countries, and across them as well. This is also not consistent with Cowen's argument, since the movement towards the technology frontier in the US was associated with rising median income, not rising inequality. If that's the process that rapidly-growing economies like China and India are in, then we should see less inequality, not more. And if the Great Stagnation is something that afflict the US specifically, we might expect the gap between the US and the rest of the world to narrow, not widen.

So I think a more nuanced theory is needed. Specifically, we need to be able to explain two things: stagnating median, but not mean, incomes; global, not just local, trends. So what do we know about the major ways in which the global economy has changed over the past 40 years? I think three things are most relevant:

1. The global economy has become more integrated. This is partially due to politics, as more countries opened their economies to trade and investment. Average tariff rates have fallen dramatically during the GATT/WTO tenure. Capital accounts have been opened by many countries. Additionally, technological improvements have lowered transaction costs. International trade and investment have increased dramatically as a result. The consequence of this movement is a larger (global) market with more middle- and high-income consumers, and increased competition in production. This leads to point #2.

2. The US's post-WWII advantage was conducive to broad-based growth. The US share of global manufacturing was nearly 50% immediately after the war. The other industrialized economies were mostly decimated by the war, and many countries had not yet industrialized. For an American worker during this period, a high marginal product (relative to a foreign worker) did not require large amounts of human capital. Relatively low-skilled workers could mix with (non-human) capital in fairly lucrative ways. In a sense, the median American worker was able to collect rents from the rest of the world from 1945-1973, because the de-industrialization in Europe and pre-industrialization in much of the rest of the world operated as barriers to competition. By the early 1970s those advantages had waned, and trade agreements made it difficult for the US to protect domestic workers. The increased competition from workers in Europe and the Asian NICs (which shifted to export-biased development in the 1960s-70s) led to the US's share of global manufacturing output to fall to 20-25% by 1973, where it has stayed more or less ever since. This hit high-wage/less-skilled workers in tradable industries the hardest, since those were the workers that would face international competition directly. It isn't surprising that incomes would stagnate as those "rents", born of circumstance, are competed away.

3. These same processes benefit high-skilled workers with lots of human capital, as did the technological improvements, particularly in information technology and communications. The rise of the rest has increased the market into which they can sell their labor (demand curve shifts right), but the high skills required to compete with them provide a continuing barrier to entry (supply curve sticks). Compensation for those high-skill workers (and innovators) goes up, but is stuck for everyone else. We get a weak version of "superstar economics", where the highly-skilled are able exploit lower transaction costs to sell into an ever-enlarging global market, while the lower-skilled face increased competition. It's a two-track economy.

Cowen dismisses globalization-rooted theories of the Great Stagnation (around minute 12 in the video above), but (to my knowledge) he hasn't dealt with the sort of mechanisms I'm discussing in any kind of detail. Somewhat bizarrely, Cowen also claims that modern innovations (the internet, satellite-based telephones) have not contributed to GDP very much. But then how to explain how GDP growth, and total worker productivity, have increased post-1973 at the same rate as pre-1973? Median incomes have stagnated because those innovations, unlike previous innovations in manufacturing, do not require the mobilization of huge numbers of workers to increase output. A few computer programmers or financiers can create generate output on their own.

There's another aspect to this that I think Cowen has missed. Increased inequality and a move to a superstarish economy should create more of an incentive for innovation, not less. And while Cowen complains that scientists are no longer heralded by society as they once were, innovators most definitely are. We make movies about them and their social networks, and then give awards to the movies. We make them the richest people in the world. And, contra Cowen, we have seen a lot of innovation in the past 35 years. Cowen focuses on innovations in two major areas that led to the pre-Stagnation growth: transportation and energy. He may be correct that innovation in transportation has declined, although the rise in high-speed rail (outside the US) might be one counterpoint), but part of that is because innovations in communication and information technology has made transportation less necessary. In terms of energy, there have been more breakthroughs in new energy sources from 1980-now than there was from 1945-1973.

There's more I could discuss, but this is long enough. So in short: I do not see a world economy that has stagnated overall. I don't even see a US economy (pre-2008) that has stagnated. I see a redistribution from a certain class of American workers to workers with similar skills in other countries, and to workers with very high skills in the US that can market those skills to a global economy. This doesn't have to be a bad thing, if the government can respond by encouraging innovation by high-skilled workers, and even encourage a lot of compensation for them, but provide for the rest with a fairly robust safety net. And, in fact, the major political cleavages of the present focus on precisely these issues. The political battles aren't about stagnation, but about distribution.

UPDATE: A few folks thought the graphs above are misleading, and they've got a point. So rather than just draw some lines in Powerpoint, I did a more reasonable comparison here. It doesn't change the substantive conclusion of this post, but it was worth doing.

Too Big to Fail

.
0 comments

I watched the HBO adaptation of Andrew Ross Sorkin's book last night, and I liked it quite a bit. I'm predisposed to like it, having both read the book and followed the news at the time and since then. The story is well done and accurate, the film itself is very well made. The cast is phenomenal and the acting delivers on that promise.

There isn't a whole lot of overt politics in it, but politics is like a fog hanging over everything in the story. Government actors routinely feel constrained by democratic politics, and end up being all but forced to make decisions that they despise. Politicians try to use the crisis for electoral gain. Private sector actors try to collect as many rents as they can, and in the end some of them get quite a lot, while others get nearly none. The movie is pessimistic in general.

Hank Poulsen (excellently played by William Hurt) is portrayed as something of a tortured saint overcome by events. Somewhat odd, given both his rough real-life demeanor and his involvement in the excesses that culminated in the financial crisis, but I believe the portrayal of his moral judgment is true to life. Anyway, William Hurt probably can't play anything but a noble figure -- at one point an aide tells him to get some sleep, as he looks worn down; except he doesn't -- but there is perhaps some nobility in the way Poulsen abandoned his guiding principles when events changed. I guess that's a matter of opinion.

Geithner (Billy Crudup) is a crass-talking pragmatist who seems to have no ideology at all, other than "don't let this blow up". Bernanke (Paul Giamatti) pops in from time to time to remind everyone of the gravity of the situation for the entire economy, not just their firms. I have no idea if the rest of the cast -- notables include Fuld (James Woods), Dimon (Bill Pullman), Blankfein (Evan Handler), Thain (Matthew Modine), Mack (Tony "Monk" Shalhoub), Buffett (Ed Asner), plus Topher Grace and Cynthia Nixon as Treasury Dept officials -- match their characters well or poorly, but the overall ensemble works very well. The dialogue and plot move quickly, and I fear that viewers without a fairly strong base of prior knowledge will have difficulty following what's happening. There are a few moments when characters (semi-awkwardly) try to break down what's going on for a slow-on-the-uptake staffer or Congressperson, but it's fairly clearly for the benefit of the audience. That's fine; those instances are few and brief and necessary.

Most of all, one gets the same sense from the film as from the book: nobody understood just what they were up against. Every CEO thought his (they were/are all men) firm was stronger than it was. Every regulator had no idea what was going on in those firms. Nobody understood how susceptible they were to a run. Nobody seemed to be aware of how reliant they all were on AIG, and how fragile AIG was. When Poulsen gets on his knees before Nancy Pelosi (a true anecdote), it's hard to tell whether he's asking for help or to be put out of his misery.

The story is about ignorance, throughout the financial sector and indeed the broader economy. And when things go wrong, the ignorant panic. And when panic sets in, the game's up. It's a confidence game.

The parts of the movie that fall the flattest are the ones that try to "humanize" some of the characters. Poulsen agonizing to his wife. Buffett entertaining his grandkids. Fuld cursing the gods (over and over). There isn't very much of that, but the film could still do with less. Other than those minor distractions, I liked it quite a lot.

Monday, June 6, 2011

China's Growing Pains

. Monday, June 6, 2011
0 comments

Jon Western goes to China, and comes away impressed. Not impressed with China's improvements, although that too, but with its challenges. In a way, they are the same problems the US faces, but magnified:

1. ... In many ways, America's challenges with the future of Social Security pale in comparison to what China faces in the coming decades...

2. ... This has led to rising inequality in housing consumption as well as a new homeless population. Furthermore, while the financial industry is largely protected because of strict regulations and high downpayment requriements (a problem that ironically exacerbates the challenges to reduce domestic savings rates and jump start domestic consumption among young males), the housing prices -- especially in urban cities -- are at all-time speculative highs and many analysts now anticipate major price corrections that could well send significant shock waves through the economy. ...

3. Though China's domestic industry has grown more competitive throughout the world, there is some question about the degree and magnitude of technology upgrades in its domestic industries -- a key requirement for future development and growth. ...

For us IR scholars, we tend to focus on the data points that suggest American decline -- the US budget deficit, its military over-commitments, and the dysfunctional national politics and such. Yet, if we look closer at the internal issues within China, despite its impressive levels of economic growth over the past two decades, it's not at all clear that we are on the verge of some kind of global power transition -- at least not any time soon.


We've sounded similar notes before here, and I think it is important to remind people that growth is a long, uneven process. Over the past three decades China has shown a lot of resilience and agility, but the challenges continue to mount. I'm not a China doomsayer -- I think they'll continue to grow and modernize -- but it won't necessarily be at a linear pace. And in terms of global power, there is too much space, and too many intervening variables, to be talking in terms of "power transition" yet. China has quite a lot of maturing to do before then.

Sunday, June 5, 2011

The International Forex Network, 1998-2010

. Sunday, June 5, 2011
8 comments















This weekend I got bored of cleaning some BIS banking data, so decided to play around with their foreign exchange data while watching the Cardinals beat up on the Cubs. There's less of those data, so it was easy to quickly get it cleaned and loaded into R. From there, I made the above graphs. The BIS only collects these data every three years, so the above visualizations represent the last five surveys, covering 1998-2010 (data here)*. These are bilateral ties, e.g. the USD<->EUR ties represent the nominal dollar value of all transactions between those two currencies. The thickness of the tie represents the amount of those transactions, divided by a constant (75) for all periods to make the visualization better. The size of the nodes represents the percentage of total forex transactions involving that currency.

These are quick-and-dirty. I used a simple Fruchterman-Reingold layout to emphasize centrality. Some currencies didn't exist for the whole series -- the euro in 1998; in later periods the franc, mark, ECU (XEU), and "Other EMS" which were rolled into the euro -- but I just gave them zero ties rather than spend the time to remove the actual nodes. (Hey, it's a weekend blog post.) The non-existent currencies are easy to see, as they are disconnected from the rest of the network. Just pretend they aren't there. Also, as I type this I realize that node size for "Other currencies" (Oth) is wrong because I inadvertently left some minor ones out, but the ties are correct and the node size wouldn't change by much since those are all small currencies.

Still, there's some interesting stuff to see. Most immediately obvious, the amount of foreign exchange increased noticeably from 1998-2010, as evidenced by the increasing thickness of the ties across the period. There was a 20% jump just from 2007-2010, which the BIS attributes mostly to technological improvements that lowered transaction costs and high-frequency trading.

Perhaps more surprising is the fact that the shape of the network has changed very little over the past dozen years. The US was the most central node, and the largest in 1998. The increased activity in the intervening years hasn't changed that at all. In 1998, the US was involved in 86.8% of all foreign exchange transactions**. In 2010, the number was 84.9%. The US's centrality (by this measure) peaked in 2001, when 89.9% of forex transactions involved the dollar. Similarly, despite much fanfare the euro has not moved to an especially central position. In 1998 the German mark (30.5%) and French franc (5%) were involved in 35.5% of forex transactions; in 2010 the euro (which absorbed not only the mark and france but other currencies as well) was one of the currencies traded in 39.1% of transactions. The yen decreased very slightly from 1998-2010 (21.7% to 19%), and the pound sterling increased slightly (11% to 12.9%), but in general the network changed very little. The Chinese yuan increased its share by 900% from 2004-2010... but was still on one side of less than 1% of forex transactions in 2010 (from 0.1% to 0.9%). This is shocking: despite all their growth over the past dozen years, in which their GDP has nearly quintupled, the world's second largest economy (third if we consider the eurozone as a collective, as we should for these purposes) is involved in fewer than 1/200 foreign exchange transactions. Nothing else changed much either. There are more thick ties in 2010 than there was in 1998, but all of them include the USD.

USD<->EUR transactions accounted for 28% of all transactions in 2010, close to its 2001 peak of 30%. USD<->JPY was second, with 14%. No other pair had more than 9%, and no pair that excluded USD had more than 3%. The extreme inequality in these relationships is shown by the fact that almost every currency in the network above is tied to the USD in all periods. Very few are tied to any others, short of EUR<->GBP and EUR<->JPY. China, in particular, is conspicuously weakly-tied considering the fact that it is the world's second-largest economy and it engages in so much trade.

There's been a lot of talk in recent years about a "post-American world", and the rise of a multilateral international monetary system to replace the US's "unipolar moment" in the 1990s. Several countries have spoken loudly about trying to displace the dollar as the world's reserve currency, replacing it with the IMF's SDRs or an international basket. These data indicate that such discussion may be premature. While it's possible that such a transition could happen in the future, there has been very little movement in that direction over the past dozen years. Given the fact that complex networks with an unequal topology have a habit of reinforcing themselves over time, we should qualify claims that the US dollar's role in international currency markets is in terminal decline.

*The BIS site says that there have been eight surveys, but the data I downloaded only had the five I present.

**Percentages in this paragraph, and this paragraph only, are out of 200% rather than 100% because each transaction involves a pair.

Saturday, June 4, 2011

On Blanchard on Capital Flows and the IMF

. Saturday, June 4, 2011
4 comments

Oliver Blanchard went to a IMF conference on capital flows, and wrote up some thoughts. It's well worth reading the whole (short) post, if only to see where the IMF's thinking on this is right now, but I want to highlight a few bits.

First, while the issue of capital controls is fraught with ideological overtones, it is fundamentally a technical one, indeed a highly technical one. Put simply, governments have five tools to adjust to capital flows: monetary policy, fiscal policy, foreign exchange intervention, prudential tools, and capital controls. The challenge is to find, for each case, the right combination.


Regular readers will guess that I disagree with this completely. The issue of capital controls is not just "fraught with ideological overtones", it is also fraught with distributionary consequences. If governments choose to restrict capital flows using one of the five tools Blanchard lists, then they will be benefitting some groups over others. Which of the five they employ will also involve winners and losers. From this perspective there is no "right" combination, only choices that advantage some members of (domestic and global) society and disadvantage others. The challenge for political leaders is to find the combination that will allow them to remain in office. The challenge for interest groups is to push for the combinations that will benefit them. But this is not a technocratic problem, or at least not just one.

Blanchard gets close to understanding this a bit later, when he writes:

The nature of specific investors must inform the policy choices. We often think of inflows and outflows as coming from primarily from decisions by foreign investors. The reality is that many of these inflows and outflows often come from decisions by domestic investors. When this is the case, targeting nonresidents is largely misguided.


Layna Mosley, one of my professors, has done a lot of very good work examining how, when, and to what extent international investors place pressures on domestic governments*. There is less work (that I know of) that seeks to explain how, when, and to what extent domestic political actors (including investors) pressure their governments for certain types of policies related to capital flows. But surely this is a political question that requires a political answer. To the extent that the IMF isn't thinking about those issues they are probably missing the boat.

It is not clear that the diversity of approaches we observe in practice comes from different circumstances, or from suboptimal responses. It was interesting to observe for example that Chile relies on foreign exchange intervention, not on capital controls, but India, instead, relies on capital controls, not on foreign exchange intervention. Are these corner solutions really optimal?


Again... what is meant by optimal? Different policies will benefit different actors. In many of the cases under discussion there is no reason to think that we're on the Pareto frontier, but even if we are the actual policy choices reflect distributional concerns. Instead of trying to figure out whether these policy choices are optimal, we should be thinking of them in terms of bargaining theory. And because these policies involve international as well as domestic actors, we need to complicate the model to include multiple levels of analysis. Blanchard seems to realize this towards his conclusion.

There were some issues that I would like to have seen explored more fully.

One was the multilateral angle. As my IMF colleague Min Zhu said in his opening remarks, “ensuring that countries reap the full benefits of capital flows is a shared responsibility between advanced and emerging market economies, between surplus and deficit countries, between capital-exporters and capital-importers.” The challenge is to translate this into practice. What is the actual responsibility of source countries? Should they take it into account in conducting monetary policy, and if so, how? Should we worry about the “beggar thy neighbor” effect of controls? Some of the evidence presented at the conference suggested that these spillovers across recipient countries were not very large. Theoretical and further empirical work is badly needed here.


These are good questions, and they do need more work. But they are political questions, so economists are not very well suited to answer them. I understand that Blanchard's position within the IMF means that he has to focus on the technocratic rather than the political, but if he wishes the IMF to be an effective institutions in the future he should at least be thinking of the political implications of capital flows. This has been the IMF's weakness for decades; it's high time for them to get better on this score.

*I discussed this work briefly here, but interested folks are encouraged to read the actual research (linked in that post).

Friday, June 3, 2011

Basel Politics Nothing New

. Friday, June 3, 2011
1 comments

Felix Salmon:

One of the big successes of the Basel III process was that while there were serious disagreements along the way, the governments and central banks concerned were pretty good at keeping the discussions productive and confidential. But just as with Dodd-Frank, it seems, the real difficulty is going to be in implementation, and that’s where there’s a big risk of everything becoming very political.

In the short term, the biggest winners in any fight between regulatory authorities are always going to be the banks, who will happily arbitrage differing regional regulatory regimes and take advantage of their parents’ squabbles to stay out drinking all night. In the long term, however, even the banks would ultimately prefer a single global regulatory regime with clear ground rules and a level playing field — something which lets them concentrate on their main job, of banking, rather than expending enormous effort on lobbying and loopholes.


A few relatively minor quibbles:

1. I would stress that it makes little sense to frame this in terms of "big risk of everything becoming very political". Everything has already been political. The entire Basel negotiation process was political (see also here, here, and here). The time schedule for implementation was political. The terms of implementation (and definitions of implementation) remain political. The political nature of every step in the Basel process is not only in line with the Basel III history, but with previous Basel accords as well, as a paper (no math) Thomas and I co-wrote argues.

2. Saying that banks would prefer a level playing field neglects the very important point that not all level playing fields are the same. Banks in some countries would prefer one type of field, while banks in others would prefer a different field altogether. The battle is not over whether or not there should be a common set of broad standards; it's over what those standards will be. And on this point, not all banks have homogenous preferences. Large, well-established banks would prefer stricter regulations (in some areas at least), as those are likely to reinforce their market position and create barriers to entry. This is why this is a political battle.

3. This is not just an EU v. US battle. The EU is split along some important lines, as one of the FT articles Salmon links hints:

Mr Barnier’s comments were triggered by a Financial Times story based on an unpublished draft of the impending EU legislation, which indicated that there would be more flexibility for banks with insurance subsidiaries than proposed under the Basel III guidelines.


As with the debt crisis, what is good for German banks (say) might not be good for other EU banks. The UK butted heads with other EU members repeatedly during the Basel negotiations.

All to say, the political nature of Basel III has been present all along.

Thursday, June 2, 2011

Actually, Let's Not Start a Trade War With China Just Now

. Thursday, June 2, 2011
8 comments



(click for larger image)

Brad DeLong links to Jared Bernstein, who suggests some policies that Obama could pursue (without deficit spending) to help the U.S. employment malaise. Many of them are fine, but this one isn't:

Currency Management: this would be a very bad time to let up on countries who subsidize their exports by suppressing their currency values in foreign exchange markets, most notably China. I’d push the Levin bill on this. And it’s bipartisan: the darn thing got 99 R votes in the last Congress!


The Levin bill proposes slapping tariffs on goods coming from countries that manipulate their exchange rates to boost exports. Levin has proposed a variant of it for years (here's one from 2006), but finally got traction during the recession. Krugman agrees that this is a good idea, but I think there are a number of problems with it.

1. It's most likely illegal. If China is violating trade rules with its exchange rate policies, then the USTR should take them to the WTO. The fact that that hasn't been done at any point over the past decade, despite the fact that it would have been politically popular, indicates to me that the USTR believes it would lose such a case. There's a reason why exchange rate policy has been referred to the IMF (which conducts monitoring and surveillance but has no authority) rather than the WTO. It's also not clear that China is violating any WTO rules. For one thing, the WTO doesn't have a lot to say about which exchange rate regimes are legal and which aren't. And although using the exchange rate to subsidize exports could be illegal, there's a fairly high bar to clear. This (several years old) thread on the excellent International Economic Law and Policy blog describes the three simultaneous conditions under which currency manipulation could be WTO-illegal: 1. It must entail a "financial contribution"; 2. It must be specific; 3. It must confer a benefit on exporters. The comments to that post get into specifics, but according to IELP, "If [currency policy] is contingent in law or de facto upon export performance, it is then prohibited and deemed specific automatically".

The graph above shows the nominal dollar-yuan exchange rate over the past five years. Does it look like the exchange rate is contingent upon export performance? The yuan has appreciated against the dollar by nearly 25% over the past five years, and I'm not sure the trend clearly indicates responsiveness to changes in Chinese export performance.

2. There are growing concerns about inflation in the U.S. These concerns may be misguided, but they play well in Republican circles and among certain Governors at the Federal Reserve. Slapping an import tariff on China would cause immediate price spikes across a wide range of consumer goods, which would likely lead to increased calls for the Fed to tighten monetary policy. That, of course, would not be good for economic recovery. Nor would it be good for standards of living. A Chinese undervaluation of the yuan is equivalent to the Chinese giving us free money. Let me say that again: a Chinese undervaluation of the yuan is equivalent to them giving us free money. It's not clear to me that trading lower standards of living for more jobs is a net win. Jobs are certainly important, but they're not the only important thing.

Moreover, as we've discussed on this blog repeatedly, the nominal exchange rate is less significant than the real exchange rate, and the real exchange rate is shifting faster than the nominal rate as inflation in China out-paces inflation in the U.S.

3. It's not at all clear that a tariff targeted specifically at China's exchange rates would have any effect on U.S. jobs. Not only would importers suffer, but there is no reason to believe that manufacturing jobs would come back to the U.S. en masse. Manufacturing employment was collapsing before the recession (see also here), and even if China lost some jobs via a U.S. tariff those jobs would likely go to Vietnam and Taiwan and South Korea and any number of other places before coming back here. A tariff would make U.S.-produced goods cheaper relative to Chinese goods (in U.S. markets), but would not affect the price of Vietnamese goods at all. The magnitude of this shift, and the timing of it, isn't obvious to me, and to some extent it offsets #2 above, but the world is dynamic.

4. Those dynamics are not limited to economics; they also involve politics. The Chinese would not simply accept tariffs as the new cost of doing business. They would fight back. First, they would take the U.S. to the WTO. Second, they would likely enact retaliatory tariffs. The WTO cases would take years to be resolved (i.e. hopefully after the recovery from the recession), but the tariffs would immediately damage U.S. exporters. Obama's stated policy goal is to double American exports over the next several years. It's going to be hard to do that if you can't sell into the world's fastest-growing major market, now the second-largest economy on the globe.

5. The U.S. runs the risk of pot-meets-kettle reactions from the rest of the globe. The world already believes that U.S. monetary policy, with interest rates at 0% and two rounds of quantitative easing already conducted, constitute "currency manipulation" of a different sort. Putin called it "hooliganism", Brazil imposed capital controls, S. Korea has expressed concern about exchange rates at the G20, etc. I agree with Krugman and others that this criticism is over-blown; the U.S. is in a deep recession and should be using monetary expansion to help get out of it. But a round of tariffs targeting exchange rate policy will leave the U.S. open to a dose of its own medicine. Other countries are already wary of U.S. policy, and more aggressive measures could quickly lead to a cycle of more prevalent beggar-thy-neighbor policies. Right now it is critical that international economic cooperation move forward, not back. We've seen from the Japan crisis how badly economies are damaged when global supply chains are disrupted.

6. The U.S. needs to know its role. The global economy is still terribly damaged. 1937 isn't the worst analogue. Right now the U.S. needs to do everything it can to keep markets open, maintain international cooperation, provide liquidity into the global system, and maintain a market for goods. In other words, it needs to live up to Kindleberger's charge. That involves allowing some free-riding. It involves setting policy based on global, not domestic, circumstances. Myopically trying to get back every lost job as quickly as possible runs the risk of damaging global economic relations over the medium- and long-run, which could easily have adverse effects on growth and prosperity. Letting China sell us goods at below-market prices seems like a very small price to pay for averting a seriously negative outcome.

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

The Politics of Stealth Bailouts and Plausible Deniability in the Eurozone

. Wednesday, June 1, 2011
4 comments




My post yesterday on how the German banking sector can likely withstand a restructuring of Greek debt touched on, but did not dwell on, another important aspect of the Euro crisis: it's not just the banks in the Eurocore that own debt in the periphery, but also the governments. I wrote "The taxpayers have already loaned Greece a lot of money, either directly or via the ECB" and quoted a Der Spiegel report that said:

Taxpayers might need to step in, as might the savings banks that are owned by municipalities.

In addition, the European Central Bank (ECB) has bought up tens of billions of euros of Greek sovereign bonds. Because the Bundesbank, Germany's central bank, holds more than a quarter of the ECB's capital, it would have to take its share of losses accordingly.


This latter point is the subject of this Martin Wolf column that has made the rounds of the blogosphere (Salmon, McArdle, Krugman) and yielded the above graphs. Wolf's column is provocative -- he begins with "The eurozone, as designed, has failed." -- but makes a very important point about the centrality of the European banking system to the broader regional economy:

The role of banks is central. Almost all of the money in a contemporary economy consists of the liabilities of financial institutions. In the eurozone, for example, currency in circulation is just 9 per cent of broad money (M3). If this is a true currency union, a deposit in any eurozone bank must be the equivalent of a deposit in any other bank. But what happens if the banks in a given country are on the verge of collapse? The answer is that this presumption of equal value no longer holds. A euro in a Greek bank is today no longer the same as a euro in a German bank. In this situation, there is not only the risk of a run on a bank but also the risk of a run on a national banking system. This is, of course, what the federal government has prevented in the US.


The ECB doesn't technically have legal authority as a lender of last resort (although it's taken on part of that function since 2007), so domestic central banks as well as the US Federal Reserve have had to fill that role. The upshot? Central banks in the Eurocore, such as the German Bundesbank, are now heavily exposed to debt from the periphery. At current rates of lending they're likely to run out of cash by 2013, and unlike the US Fed, they can't just print more. This is becoming a slow-moving liquidity crisis, in other words, and as London Banker wrote a few days ago, liquidity crises (such as occurred in the Fall of 2008) are really nasty. As Wolf notes, this is serious business:

Government insolvencies would now also threaten the solvency of debtor country central banks. This would then impose large losses on creditor country central banks, which national taxpayers would have to make good. This would be a fiscal transfer by the back door.


In a sense this is already a fiscal transfer, since debtor countries are spending the funds on financing the state, and the creditor central banks don't have a printing press. So why, given that a fiscal transfer was needed, was it done in a way that risks the solvency and credibility of Eurocore central banks? Because they are unelected. Such a large transfer plan on top of the EFSF is unlikely to have been approved by voters in the Eurocore, as my post from yesterday indicates. And as Hans-Warner Sinn notes (via Henry Farrell's Twitter), the size of these hidden transfers "dwarfs the parliament-approved bailouts extended to Greece, Ireland and Portugal." It's easy to see why European leaders would opt for a bailout mechanism that was less transparent, and that involved non-elected actors pulling the strings: it allows bailout financing to continue, but with plausible deniability.

Sinn draws an analogy between the situation in the Europeriphery and Britain in 1992, when Soros sank the pound by selling it off. Eventually, the British Treasury ran out of marks and francs to exchange for pounds, and was forced to devalue. Soon, writes Sinn, there won't be enough funds in Bundesbank to cover the borrowing in the periphery. At that point, the Euro will collapse like the pound. If Sinn is right, then the Euro has two years. I've been saying for awhile now that 2013 was key to the Euro's future. 2013 is officially when haircuts begin, and when new bailout lending ends. It's also when the "stealth bailout", through the central banking system in the EU, can no longer sustain itself. At that point, either the peripheral economies have righted the ship by balancing the budget and/or regaining access to private credit markets, or they exit the Euro.

So right now it's a waiting game. The Eurocore doesn't want a restructuring, which would cost taxpayers (and banks) billions, if it can avoid it. The Europeriphery doesn't want the economic collapse that would accompany a Euro-exit. But both of them want the other to pick up more of the tab. But there's not much more the periphery can pick up, with unemployment above 11% in Portugal, 14% in each of Greece and Ireland, and 20% in Spain. And there's not much more the core can pick up without risky the solvency of their domestic central banks. More direct fiscal funding mechanisms look to be politically impossible. Maybe one of those things changes by 2013, but I wouldn't bet on it.

The World's Central Banker

.
0 comments

More information (via Felix Salmon) about how the Fed acted as the lender of last resort for foreign firms during the 2008 crisis:

File under “things you never knew the Fed did during the financial crisis”: an $80 billion loan scheme known as ST OMO, which was so obscure that even Barney Frank had no idea it existed when he required the Fed to turn over its lending data in his Dodd-Frank bill. ...

Why was the Fed so reluctant to discuss this program? After all, Fed spokesman Jeffrey Smith had nothing but great stuff to say about it to Ivry, gushing about how it “helped alleviate strains in financial markets and support the flow of credit to U.S. households and businesses”. You’d think if it was so great, the Fed wouldn’t be so quiet about it.

One possible reason is hinted at in the charts above. They cover four banks: Credit Suisse, Deutsche Bank, BofA, and RBS. (RBS is still referred to, quaintly, under its old name of Greenwich Capital, the shop bought by NatWest before NatWest was bought by RBS.) The three European banks all borrowed 11-figure sums from the facility, while the one American bank barely used it. ...

But it does seem that the governments of Switzerland, Germany, France, and the UK should all be sending thank-you letters to 33 Liberty Street if they haven’t already done so: it’s entirely possible that the New York Fed bailed out their banks without those governments even knowing about it. That’s just how generous we are, in this country.


I've written about similar actions here and here. The Fed has been criticized for not doing more to stimulate the economy since 2008, but the actions it took to stabilize the international financial system would make Kindleberger smile.

International Political Economy at the University of North Carolina
 

PageRank

SiteMeter

Technorati

Add to Technorati Favorites