And another one. Be interesting to see how this plays out.
(Video above has some strong language.)
Update: Havel on Kim Jon Il, from 2004. (Via half of Twitter.)
IPE @ UNC
Bookshelf
Tags
Sunday, December 18, 2011
(Do Not) RIP, Kim Jong Il
Labels: North KoreaSunday, September 25, 2011
Developments in the DPRK
Labels: North KoreaI'm fascinated by accounts of North Korea, probably because the Hermit Kingdom is so isolated from the sources of information that I usually access. That may be changing a bit as North Korea tries to ramp up its tourism industry by luring (primarily) the Chinese nouveau-riche above the 38th parallel. Usually portrayals of the DPRK are pretty grim, but these photos from a journalist who went on a cruise have some moments of light and contain a lot of beauty. However the economic news is not so good:
The rationing system, the backbone of the socialist planned economy, has nearly collapsed. Some 4 million people still live on rations — 2.6 million in Pyongyang and 1.2 million soldiers.
But a senior South Korean government official said 20 million North Koreans rely absolutely on the underground economy.
“A North Korean family needs 90,000-100,000 North Korean won for living costs per month, but workers at state-run factories or enterprises earn a mere 2,000-8,000 won,” the source said. “So North Koreans have no choice but to become market traders, cottage industrialists or transport entrepreneurs to make up for shortages.” ...
“Ordinary North Koreans have become so dependent on the private economy that they get 80-90 percent of daily necessities and 60-70 percent of food from the markets,” the security official said.Obviously the situation is not sustainable in the long term. It will be interesting to see if North Korea begins making gradual Cuba-like reforms after the transition of power from Kim Jong-il to his son Kim Jong-un.
Thursday, December 23, 2010
The High Politics of ROK/DPRK Trade
Labels: North Korea, TradeInter-Korean trade has fallen about 30 percent this year, largely affected by South Korea's move to cut almost all business relations with North Korea after the North sank one of its naval ships in a torpedo attack in March, the customs office said Wednesday.
This is to be expected. But this surprised me:
According to data provided by the Korea Customs Service (KCS), trade between the two Koreas amounted to US$464 million during the January-November period, down from $649 million recorded a year earlier.
That is more trade than I thought. North Korea's GDP is ~ $27bn, so that $650mn in trade represents about 4% of DPRK GDP*. To put that in perspective, in 2009 the U.S. and China traded $366bn in goods, or about 3.8% of (U.S.) GDP.
Perhaps that plays into why the DPRK backed down earlier this week: they literally can't afford to keep playing high stakes poker when they're so short-stacked. As any poker player knows, "in a heads-up game, the size of your stacks is as important as the cards in your hand". The ROK is in a position to lean on the DPRK, the DPRK doesn't have a bankroll to fall back on, and both know it. Especially because much more than just $650mn is at stake:
Despite such a sharp shrinkage, trade through the Kaesong industrial complex, tallied in a separate statistic, remained robust. Trade amounted to $1.31 billion during the 11-month period, up 62 percent from a year earlier. ...
South Korea is the North's second-largest trade partner after China. A suspension of inter-Korean business would significantly impact the reclusive communist nation's efforts to secure cash, according to experts.
Long and short: the ROK can trade with the U.S., Japan, and everyone else in the world. The DPRK can't. There's an important asymmetry here that the ROK can, and apparently is, using to its advantage.
*To be clear, that $650mn is not entirely on the North's end. It's total trade. But the North exports more to the South than vice versa, and is definitely more dependent on that trade. From the article:
South Korea's exports to the North came to $130 million during the cited period, down 28 percent a year earlier, while imports dropped 29 percent on-year to $334 million, the data showed.
Via.
Monday, December 20, 2010
Korea
Labels: China, International Relations, North Korea, Security Dilemma, US-South KoreaWhen I went to bed last night the news sites were all saying that a resumption of the conflict on the Korean peninsula was possible -- even "imminent" according to one source -- if the South proceeded with its plans to hold a military exercise in disputed territory. I went to bed thinking that I'd wake up to no news, which would certainly be good news. That turns out to have been right, so here's some thoughts on the situation.
1. The security dilemma is still the most important concept in international relations. Obviously the South is spooked by the North's nukes and occasional belligerence, and felt the need to demonstrate its defensive capabilities. The North is obviously spooked by the fact that a huge, well-funded military backed by (still) the only global superpower is right below it, and it can't necessarily count on its only ally (China) for much support.
2. Schelling is still boss. He first identified the "cliff-dancing" strategy in his 1960 book, and it is still relevant. The South just danced a bit closer to the brink, and it worked.
3. North Korea is very weak, but it is not crazy. Neither impression is the one Kim Jong Il wishes to leave, but that conclusion is inescapable at this point. The North threatened retaliation if the South conducted this exercise, but immediately back-tracked since those threats were clearly not credible. In fact, it appears that once its bluff was called it was willing to do quite a lot to walk back its earlier threats. It offered possibly-meaningful concessions in negotiations with Bill Richardson, including resumption of the six party talks, access to its nuclear facilities by outside inspectors, and the return of the remains of U.S. soldiers that died during the Korean War. I'm not at all suggesting that the South should continue to posture in this way, but in this case it appears to have worked.
4. Nukes only get you so much deterrence capability. Namely, they can (perhaps) act as a repellent, but cannot compel others to
5. For all of the talk about shifting power structures in Asia, the U.S. and its ally still won the day. Not just by holding the exercise without retaliation, which was sort of a "remind them who's boss" maneuver, but also by the response of the other regional powers. China and Russia implored the South to stand down, to no avail, indicating a clear lack of power and influence in the region. This follows the U.S.'s decision to conduct joint exercises with South Korea last month, a move China opposed because it occurred in China's "exclusive economic zone" but did nothing to prevent.
6. This incident is really the first time the Obama administration has been willing to stare down some of the U.S.'s antagonists, and he won: the other side blinked (DPRK) or sat down (China). Not only the military exercises, which not only involved moving the USS George Washington strike group to the Yellow Sea, but also passed the ROK-US trade agreement. I'm not sure whether this will encourage more risk-taking by the administration or even whether it should, but it is notable.
7. Keep all of this in mind when you hear that Iran is crazy, undeterrable, will be able to marshall nuclear capabilities to blackmail the Middle East, etc. All of those ideas have been tested over the past month in Korea, and all of them have been found wanting.
UPDATE: Drezner also posted thoughts. I like his #4, but I don't buy it. I think #3 is more likely, and if true is a positive sign for the future of Asia.
Sunday, November 28, 2010
Korea
Labels: China, North Korea, Security Dilemma, US-South KoreaA former student e-mailed me and asked for advice on a paper he was writing about the Korea situation. Up until last week he had been focusing on China's role as facilitator of negotiations. He wanted my take on last's week attack, and the responses from the South, China, and the US since then. A few days late, but this was my off-the-cuff response:
I'm not sure how to read China right now. On the one hand, there is a long history of N Korea doing belligerent things to get attention, and then negotiating some agreement that gets them some aid or something in exchange for them not being stupid anymore. My first reaction is to consider their more recent actions in the same vein, given that history. In that case, you could maybe interpret China's nonplussed reaction as buying into that strategy to get all sides back to the negotiating table.
On the other hand, this recent action is more serious than past actions, and occurs in a different context: succession of power from Kim Jong Il to his son. I don't think this is going to lead to war necessarily, but I do think that it signals that the current status quo is likely untenable. The likelihood of a resumption of fighting has certainly gone way up, and S Korea appears to be losing patience. China also said (I think yesterday) that joint US-S Korean military exercises in the Pacific violated China's economic sovereignty (b/c China uses that water for shipping), which is a sign that China is not interested in marginalizing N Korea to get closer to the US and S Korea right now. Again... this could be a negotiating ploy, but then you'd have to think that both N Korea and China are bluffing. That could be correct, but I'm not very confident that it is.
Certainly the security dilemma is present, and there is some risk of spiraling. You can also think about how deterrence can have negative side effects... the US' security guarantee for S Korea could make S Korea *more* likely to retaliate and escalate the conflict. They know they have a powerful ally, so that will give them much more confidence than they'd have otherwise.
The US obviously does not guarantee N Korea's security, but China might. If so, then you might have a situation in which neither side (US or China) wants to escalate and both sides know it. In that case, N Korea might think that it can act with impunity. Think of it this way: N Korea knows that neither the US nor China want war, and will do whatever it takes to prevent it. The N Korean leadership is also going through a power shift, and the new leaders will want to demonstrate to their citizens that they are strong leaders, and worthy of support. What better way to do it than to attack S Korea in a limited fashion, and not suffer any repercussions? It's true that the only reason there won't be repercussions is because of China and the US, but the N Korean citizens don't know that. (There's a domestic politics information asymmetry too.)
Anyway, that's how I'm reading the situation right now.
Thursday, June 24, 2010
Worth a Shot, I Guess
Labels: Crazy, North KoreaKim Jong-Il never ceases to amaze:
Citing costs induced by six decades of American hostility, Jong-Il has rummaged up his calculator, revived his old grudges, and delivered a tab to the U.S. to the tune of $65 trillion -- plus tax.
KCNA, North Korea's official state-run news agency, has asserted North Korea's "justifiable right" to collect financial compensation from the U.S. for an alleged six decades worth of antagonism -- one trillion dollars for every year since the Korean peninsula was divided in 1945.
The check's in the mail, Dear Leader. While you wait for it, why don't you not send the DPRK's soccer team to the gulag? That would be dumb.
Friday, May 28, 2010
How to Out-Crazy Kim Jong Il
Labels: Crazy, Game Theory, North KoreaDrezner notes that North Korea is playing chicken, and Carpenter asks how we can out-crazy the craziest regime on earth (they diavlog about it here):
If this is actually a game of chicken as Dan argues, how might the policy dilemma be framed in such a way that North Korea, who actually wants to avoid war, might start to believe that it's not the craziest party in the equation anymore or the one with the least to lose?
Easy. Fire Gates and appoint George W. Bush as Secretary of Defense, and pass a constitutional amendment giving him power to do whatever he wants. Game. Set. Match.
Saturday, January 9, 2010
Nobody Could Have Seen This Coming
Labels: Currencies, North Korea
Remember that currency revaluation in North Korea? Yeah, that's not going so well:
North Korea’s currency reform has apparently failed to tame inflation. The state has paid the first salaries since the shock currency reform late last year, with the State Security Department and the Ministry of Public Security, the frontline agencies dedicated to protection of the regime, paying soldiers 6,000 won each — 3,000 won in average monthly pay plus a 3,000 won bonus.
Soldiers usually received about 3,000 won in the old currency. That this effectively doubled means the currency reform, which exchanged old won for new at a rate of 100:1, has not been able to stop inflation. ...
But commodity prices skyrocketed. Inflation is soaring as market traders are hoarding goods, anticipating that the real value of the new currency will plummet. According to a North Korean source, 1 kg of rice cost about 30 won right after the currency reform but is now closing in on 1,000 won. The U.S. dollar was exchanged at the rate of 75 won to the greenback right after the currency reform but soared to 400 won in late December. There is speculation that it is now only a matter of time before the rate will reach 3,000 won, the same as the unofficial exchange rate of the old won.
Market traders are angry as they have realized that they were robbed of nearly everything they earned. A former senior North Korean official said, “The latest currency reform is more cruel than the previous reform in 1992. It’s tantamount to the state confiscating 99 percent of people’s money.”
It's about time for North Korea to test-fire another missile, eh? That always seems to distract from domestic turmoil.
Tuesday, December 1, 2009
North Korea Redenominates Currency
Labels: Black Market, Currencies, North Korea, RedenominationInternational news agencies and informants inside of North Korea are reporting that North Korea issued an order yesterday morning to redenominate the won, North Korea's currency. The Central Bank of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) has slashed two zeroes off of its currency and has placed limits on how much of the old currency can be converted into new bank notes.
Choi Soo-young, an expert on the North Korean economy at the government-financed Korea Institute for National Unification in Seoul, said: “The primary aim is to control inflation. But the North also wants to stop the [black and unofficial] market[s] from prospering too fast.”North Korea's black market in both currency conversion and goods have flourished over the last decade years as the government turned a blind eye to their presence. But, the government has begun shutting down unofficial food and goods markets across the country as it tries to reassert its control over the economy. The DPRK also reinstituted its rationing policy in 2005. Under this rationing policy, the government runs stores where North Koreans go to purchase their necessities at low, state-subsidized prices. One reason the government has sought to reassert its power over the domestic food and goods markets,
is that the mix of state and private activity has fueled inflation, partly by drawing goods that would otherwise be sold at low, state-subsidized prices into more lucrative private markets.
Saturday, November 14, 2009
Markets in Everything?
Labels: North Korea, Soccer
I came across the above t-shirt while browsing an online store. It's a fan t-shirt celebrating the North Korean soccer team. Demand must not have been brisk, because the t-shirt is now on clearance. I guess that's no surprise.
Anyway, for those interested in following North Korea's economy (what there is of it), there's a blog for that.
Friday, October 30, 2009
Revealed Preferences
Labels: North KoreaIt was Kim Il Sung who used to say, “Communism is rice,” meaning the system would succeed by giving the people enough to eat. The famine was caused by mismanagement and the inability to adapt to the collapse of the Soviet Union and the economic transformation of China. …
By the way, Kim Jong Il is famous for being one of the biggest foodies in Asia. Throughout the nineteen-eighties and well into the famine, he flew couriers around the world to procure delicacies for his own palate — fresh fish from Tokyo for his sushi, cheese from France, caviar from Uzbekistan and Iran, mangoes and papaya from Thailand.
From a fascinating New Yorker article about life in the Hermit Kingdom.
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Some good videos
Labels: Bloggingheads, Economics, Iran, North KoreaDaniel Drezner v. David Frum on North Korea, Iran, and John Bolton.