For those who prefer analysis to tropes, here's a nice rundown (via Stephen Walt) of the research on the effects of allowing gays to serve openly in the military. They survey the experience of other countries, as well as the U.S. military's own studies. Short version: almost no bad effects excepting (very minor) short-run disruptions from implementing the policy, and many positive benefits beyond that.
None of the above would have to be true for me to support DADT repeal -- the best argument is the one that invokes justice and liberty -- but it's always nice when empirical facts appear to line up with my normative preferences.
As a side note, I've always found the (only) case against DADT repeal -- that it would adversely affect unit cohesion and morale, which apparently is the greatest end of modern society -- to be immensely insulting to the troops. It's basically saying that our servicemen and women are so immature that they can't deal with a situation that college kids in dorms manage every day. It's profoundly disrespectful to say such a thing to those we ask to kill and die on our behalf, and I have enough regard for them to think that notion is ridiculous.
And that's to say nothing about the disrespect shown to those who wish to serve openly, but are told that they would weaken the military by their very presence.
In fact, the studies cited in the Palm Center's report say the opposite is true: a policy whereby gays cannot serve openly weakens cohesion and morale, perhaps by breeding suspicion and ostracization of those believed to be gay (whether they are or not), and by preventing gay people that serve while in the closet to fully assimilate into the group. This should have been obvious to anyone who has thought about it for more than 3 seconds.
I try not to get on my high horse too often on this blog, but DADT was a terrible policy in every respect. Good riddance.
IPE @ UNC
IPE@UNC is a group blog maintained by faculty and graduate students in the Department of Political Science at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The opinions expressed on these pages are our own, and have nothing to do with UNC.
Bookshelf
Tags
Academia Adjustment Afghanistan Africa AIG America Argentina Austerity Bailout Banking Bargaining Basel Bernanke Bias Blogging Business cycle; recession; financial crisis Cap and Trade capital controls capital flows central banks; moral hazard Chavez China China Trade Climate Change Contentious Politics Cuba Currencies Currency Crises; financial crisis Current Account Data Debt Debt; China; United States; Decession Politics Decoupling Deflation democracy Democrats; Trade policy development Diplomacy Dollar; China; Currency Manipulation; Exchange Rates dollar; exchange rate policy ECB ECB; Fed; Monetary Policy Economic Growth Economics Egypt election EMU; monetary union Environment EU; Agriculture; Common Agricultural Policy Euro Europe; labor; immigration European Union Exchange Rates Farm Bill; Agriculture FDI Fed; Monetary Policy finance financial crisis financial crisis; subprime Fiscal Policy; monetary policy; elections Fiscal Stimulus Foreign Aid Foreign Policy France Free Trade Agreements G-20 G20 Summit Game Theory Germany global recession globalization Grand Theory Great Britain Greece health care reform Hegemony Human Rights Iceland imbalance IMF immigration Incentives income distribution income inequality; globalization India Inequality inflation institutions Interests international finance International Law International Monetary System International Relations Investment IPE Iran Iraq Ireland ISA Italy Japan labor markets Latin America Libya Macroeconomics Marxism Mexico Microfinance Miscellany monetary policy Monetary policy; Federal Reserve moral hazard Narcissism Networks Nobelist Smackdown North Korea Obama Oil PIGS Pirates Political Economy Political Methodology Political Science Political Survival Political Theory Power Protectionism Protests Public Choice Public opinion Rational Choice regulation Research Review Russia Sanctions Security Dilemma security threats Soccer Social Science Sovereign Debt Spain Sports Statistics stock markets Systems Tariffs TARP Taxes TBTF Technocracy technology terrorism Trade trade policy UNC Unemployment United States US-South Korea Venezuela WTO WTO; Doha
Blog Archive
-
▼
2010
(478)
-
▼
December
(59)
- The Politics of Basel III [2/2]
- The Politics of Basel III [1/2]
- 2010 Best of the Blog, XIII
- The Vatican Gets Religion on FinReg
- 2010 Best of the Blog, XII
- 2010 Best of the Blog, XI
- Germany's Rising Tea Party Movement
- IPE Everywhere: The Original Tea Party
- 2010 Best of the Blog, X
- 2010 Best of the Blog, IX
- 2010 Best of the Blog, VIII
- 2010 Best of the Blog, VII
- 2010 Best of the Blog, VII
- 2010 Best of the Blog, VI
- RIP Denis Dutton
- 2010 Best of the Blog, V
- 2010 Best of the Blog, IV
- 2010 Best of the Blog, III
- Bizarre Geopolitical Analogy of the Day
- The Grade Inflation Prisoner's Dilemma
- 2010 Best of the Blog, II
- 2010 Best of the Blog, I
- What I've Been Reading...
- Johann Hari's People of 2010
- The Etymology of 'Tariff' and 'Austerity'
- The High Politics of ROK/DPRK Trade
- Interesting US-China Trade Developments
- IPE Everywhere: Soliciting Capital in Macedonia
- Iceland Is Not A Good Example For Running An Economy
- Postwar Macroeconomics
- On DADT Repeal
- Korea
- FOTD
- Newsflash: IMF Is Nervous of Labor Parties
- Paul Krugman on China
- UN Sanctions Against Iraq Finally Lifted
- Slutting My Way Through Macro Theory
- The "I'd Gladly Pay You Tuesday For a Hamburger To...
- Stats Nerd Post
- The Double-Standard Ethics of RCT
- From Iceland to...
- The Ignored Financial Crisis
- E Pluribus dis-Unum
- Parsing Ireland, Germany, and the Euro
- Shout It From The Rooftops
- The Darkest Age of Macroeconomics
- Interesting New Research
- Oh My
- Clarke and Dawe Explain Europe
- Saturday Morning Videos
- It Makes Sense If You Think About It Properly
- Want to Know Who Got Money from the Fed in 2008?
- Why TARP Was Good, and Why Bailout Guarantees Are ...
- When An E.U. Bailout Is A U.S. Bailout
- IR Cartooned
- Rosling on the Beeb
- Explaining Ireland
- Hegemony and Bank Bailouts
- The Political Economy of Climate Change
-
▼
December
(59)
Monday, December 20, 2010
On DADT Repeal
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment